Burnt Store Marina & Country Club

It suits buyers who want gated, amenity-focused coastal living with boat access — 57 of the 61 active homes are gated and 23 are waterfront. The marina and harbor access anchor daily life, and it feels more contained than nearby inland communities like Deep Creek. It's a strong fit if the water is central to how you want to live.

It's mid-range for the area, with a median list price of $375,000 and an average of $264 per square foot. Prices span from $165,000 to $975,000, so there's flexibility depending on whether you want a smaller condo or a larger waterfront home. You can browse the full price range against other Punta Gorda homes for sale.

The median list price is $375,000 and the median home size is about 1,547 square feet, working out to roughly $264 per square foot. Over the last 12 months, 102 homes sold at a median sold price of $360,000. That gap between list and sold reflects the room to negotiate here.

It's a buyer-friendly market with 61 active listings and homes sitting a median of 73 days before selling. Sellers are getting about 94% of their asking price on average, so there's genuine negotiating room. You can track current inventory on the live map.

The median HOA here runs about $815 per month, which reflects the gated infrastructure and marina-community amenities. Median property taxes come in around $4,710 per year. Factor both into your monthly budget, especially compared to lower-HOA inland options like Tropical Gulf Acres.